1. Fire JFJ - This is not to say he's been a terrible GM, because he hasn't. Fergie made some bad trades, but they weren't Mike MIilbury bad. He overpaid McCabe, Kubina, and Jason Blake, but did get Kaberle and Antropov signed cheap. The thing is, this will be three years with no playoffs and he has simply run out of credibility with the fans and media. The current situation (not winning Stanley Cups for 40 years and counting) is never going to change with him in charge. This board of approval nonsense and constant meddling continues to hold the Leafs down in the standings. The overall structure of the organization is counter-productive to success and needs to be replaced. That begins with firing Fergie, preferrably before he re-signs Bryan McCabe to a three-year extension.
2. Hand The Keys To Mr.Big Shot (No, not Robert Horry) - The next GM of the Leafs absolutely has to be a HUGE name. My first choice would be to hire Brian Burke away from Anaheim, and my second would be to lure Brent Sutter out of Jersey, but neither is likely to happen. But that's the type of name and hockey person Toronto has to get. One of the best, a top tier guy with a pedigree who can come in and do things HIS WAY without anyone second-guessing him. The Buds were kinda on the right track with Scotty Bowman, and even if they don't get him, hopefully he sets the terms that everyone will end up committing too. Total autonomy over hockey decisions, or as it's known around town...the Bryan Colangelo deal. That's the only way things will ever change in this organization.
3 (Sigh) Trade Mats - It's fairly obvious that Mats has to go. The haul he'd net in return (3-4 prospects or picks) is simply too much to pass up on for a team with no cap-space going forward and no legitimate Stanley Cup aspirations. I would tell Mats that the team had every intention of bringing him back as a UFA in the summer if he was willing, to hopefully a younger, quicker and better team than he was leaving.
3.5 Mats Retires as a Leaf - Mats is our Derek Jeter. Ummmm, Mats is our Jim Kelly. Ok, neither of those is right but you get the point. Mats owns the Leaf record book and has long been the face of the franchise. A few days before July 1st you pull the Paul Holmgren and trade a 3rd or 4th rounder to which ever team ends up with Mats in exchange for his rights before he hits the open market. Give Mats a 2 year/$9M contract (same as Alffy makes) with another no-trade.
4. Say Goodbye to Antropov - It makes sense for the Leafs to listen to offers for any of their players not named Steen, Wellwood, Tlusty, Colaiacovo, Stralman or Pogge. The phones won't be ringing for guys like Tucker or Blake, so the guy I would try to move would be Antropov. He has another year on his contract before he becomes unrestricted, and he's playing well enough that if he keeps it going next year he could work his way into a Mike Ribeiro type of deal. If he's still with the Leafs, that situation terrifies me. Better to move him now when he has a lot of value. At only $2M next year, almost every team in the league could afford him.
5. Beef Up Scouting and Coaching - The salary cap may have leveled the playing field on the ice, but off of it the league's most profitable franchise needs to upgrade and max-out their entire scouting and coaching departments. There is no reason Toronto shouldn't be out-spending every team significantly in these areas. It's what the Yankees and Red Sox are doing under similar circumstances.
6. NO SUITS ALLOWED - This part is embarrassing. Canada's largest city and an original six franchise with home crowds that are under-whelming at best and far too tardy. I know this rule would never work because the entire lower bowl at the ACC is a corporate schmooze-fest, but can't we fine them or something if they don't get to their seats by the 5 minute mark? Something needs to be done. You don't think staring at 4000 empty ice-level seats at the beginning of every period is demoralizing for a home team?
7. Clear Cap-Space, Re-Stock the System, and Wait for the Cavalry to Arrive - If we could somehow look into the future, to the year 2010 and beyond and see a very solid Toronto roster stocked with youth, talent and depth, with ample cap-space, I have to believe players would be lining up to sign here. I could see some players who were born in Ontario and grew up Leaf fans maybe agreeing to slight home-town discounts on their contracts. Guys around the league know that winning a Cup in Toronto would be very similar to what the players who were on the Boston Red Sox in 2004 went through, it could be a career-maker. I think that opportunity, if the proper foundation is in place, would be very enticing to all types of free-agents.